Nothing
to See Here
Nov
19 2023
Sometimes,
it's what isn't said
that's
most telling.
Perhaps
your silence is well-meant;
avoiding
offence,
or
sensible enough
to
know you don't yet
know
enough to say.
But
more likely
it's
to protect yourself.
Because
when regrets don't count,
and
intent
which
is everything
doesn't
even register,
they
will surely second-guess
unfairly
infer.
So
you wisely refrain.
Edit,
filter, suppress.
An
opinion on everything,
yet
you keep them to yourself.
Which
isn't easy
in
this cacophonous age
of
loudmouths and self-promoters,
when
sensation ratchets up
and
attention is for sale.
When
we're all self-appointed experts
on
whatever it is,
oracles
and
historians
and
perfectly informed;
solipsists
obliged
to share our wisdom
with
the many loyal followers
waiting
breathless to hear.
When
we're expected to pronounce
on
everything and anything
lest
we be judged
— as
if anyone really cares
or
anything will change.
And
when we've become so needy for approval
we
feel compelled
to
demonstrate our virtue
to
a self-righteous world
talking
back to itself.
And
then, the conspiracies of silence
when
we tacitly concur.
Like
the naked emperor
or
elephant in the room,
all
of us
prudently
pretending
nothing
to see here.
Which
is why I’m tempted
to
read between the lines
fill
in the silences.
Ignore
the
anodyne statements
and
empty bafflegab.
Because
the truth
is
somewhere in there.
Because
what isn't said
more
often than not
says
so much more than words.
Mostly,
a diatribe against social media.
In
a wired age, when even sausage and jelly bean companies feel
compelled to issue mushy pious statements about every news event; and
when every nonentity with a social media account, informed or not,
feels compelled to have an instant opinion for public consumption.
The
trouble is, if you say nothing then everyone will read who-knows-what
into your silence.
Of
course, with my utterly hermetic life and no social media, I escape
all this nonsense. I have strong opinions on most things. I like to
think they're thoughtful and well-informed. But I'm humble enough to
realize that what I think doesn't matter — actions, not words, are
all that count. And, aside from that, I keep my opinions mostly to
myself.
The
poem was inspired by seeing how every individual and institution
seemed to feel compelled to make some sort of public pronouncement
about the Israel-Hamas war. And more proximately, how everyone is
reading between the lines and reflecting their own bias in the latest
speech by Trudeau; a speech that struck me as sensible, middle of the
road, and uncontroversial. A forgettable speech should have
mercifully slipped under the radar, as does most public speaking by
congenitally risk averse politicians.
For
me, the most important thing take from this poem is the line about
intent. Because that's what's missing in the pile-on frenzy of
“cancel culture”: intent
really IS everything!